All That Glimmers

Sometimes when conducting research one stumbles upon a little gem of a story buried within withered documents or obscure archives. This happened to me recently while digging deeper into the life of Jessie Reed, above, the gold-digging Ziegfeld showgirl who married my grandfather Leonard Reno. Tucked among some yellowed newspaper clippings was an item about her and a young heiress who had an affair with Jessie’s second husband, Dan Caswell, scion of a notable family in Cleveland, Ohio. It’s a Roaring 20s fable with unexpected twists and turnarounds.
The rival girl’s name was Katherine Stevens. She was married to Dick Fagan, a handsome Dartmouth grad, but their marriage was on the rocks. She had gone to Reno to get a divorce, met Caswell along the way, flirted with him until Jessie and she had a cat-fight which became fodder for the tabloids. The affair caused Fagan to have a change of heart and he won his wife back. Jessie was left with Dan who turned out to be a spendthrift and a drunk. She divorced him and began an affair with Russell G. Colt, the heir to the arms fortune, and husband of Ethel Barrymore. So something good came of the scandal with Kate Stevens after all.

But what of young Kate? I was curious to know more about this two-timing heiress. Thanks to the internet I was able to delve into her past and uncover some interesting tales of her family. Perhaps the basic facts will be of little interest to anyone else, but I find it fascinating to glean tidbits of yesteryear’s scandals. The stories are at enough of a remove to make them harmless and amusing, rather than tragic and libelous. They are glimpses into a lost world of Jazz Age glamour, but also of the follies of fame and vanity.

Katherine’s story really begins with her notorious father, the miserly C. Amory Stevens. Long before she ran off with Dan Caswell, Kate had endured an enormous amount of press coverage relating to her father’s peculiar habit of residing in a rundown office building. Despite his reputation as the wizard of Wall Street, with millions in the bank, he chose to sleep on a cheap cot, with little or no furnishings. His clothes were threadbare; his grooming unkempt. Stevens’ wife, the socially conscious Jessie Prendergast Stevens, lived in high style in a lavish home. Why did he choose to hide out as a pauper? The press speculated it was because he was pathologically cheap. A deranged skinflint. But the truth was a bit weirder than that.

Calvin Amory Stevens had a history of provoking controversy, once hiring a female detective to masquerade as a woman of the night to lure a business rival to a house of ill repute, so that Stevens could lay claim to a fortune he had hoped to inherit outright. Stevens and his sister, a battle-ax named Mary Richardson, wrestled over family assets. His father had been a millionaire and an adventurous soul (he is mentioned in the Mormon Chronicles from 1875) who went out West to make his mark. But his legacy was tainted by scandal.
In 1885 C. Amory Stevens was sued by his sister for mismanagement of his father’s estate. But over time he was rumored to have accumulated millions of his own through investments and real estate. Or so it seemed. When his daughter Kate ran off with Fagan in a shocking elopement, Stevens was constantly described as being worth $25 million (the equivalent of a billion today). But when old man Stevens died shortly afterward, it was discovered that he had run through his vast fortune and had nothing to show for it. He had been living in squalor not because he was mad, but because he was literally broke. On April 15, 1925, Stevens’ will was valued at a negative $15,000 in debts. His mining interests in Nova Scotia, New Mexico and Virginia were worthless.

Kate’s story doesn’t end there, however. After a divorce from Fagan and a second marriage to someone named Hofer, she ended up marrying Prince Ibrahim Fazil, a wealthy Egyptian, son of Prince Ali Fazil, cousin of King Fuad. His mother was the Baroness Marthe de Carnap of Naples. A glamorous figure, he’d been involved in a juicy scandal of his own in 1922 when as a young man of 17, he had been accused of having an affair with Marie Cadman Mourilyan, the wife of his Walpole House school chum, Edmund Irvine Mourilyan. When he suspected his wife of infidelity, Mourilyan beat her, then attempted suicide. She took morphine. The case dominated the British press for several weeks as the salacious details of the suit (the husband apparently had venereal disease and collected “indecent photographs”) were splashed across the papers.
Fazil protested his innocence, claiming that he was just a friend of the lady in question. But a maid’s testimony that she’d seen him in pyjamas, kissing her mistress in bed, raised more than eyebrows. In the end, however, he was acquitted of the charges and her honor was restored. Fazil profited from his newfound reputation as a dashing ladies man. He married Kate Stevens in a lavish wedding in London. By then Prince Ibrahim was a lieutenant in the British Royal Artillery. The couple, below, remained married, as far as I know, and had children. At some point they adopted the name Foxwood.

The story was perhaps not a happily-ever-after scenario (Kate was arrested for driving under the influence in 1939), but one that was certainly a far cry from the unfortunate series of events that overtook her youthful rival, lovely Jessie Reed, who ended up in a charity hospital in Chicago, alone and destitute. Jessie died in 1940, so broke that the Ziegfeld Club had to raise funds to pay for her funeral. And where was my grandfather? According to press reports at the time, he came to visit Jessie in the hospital, bringing his latest wife along. I can’t imagine that he lingered long or that Jessie was glad to see him. He probably wanted some of his things back.
I’m not sure I’ve gained anything particularly valuable by peering into the lives of these curious souls, the Stevens and Fazil clans. Their role in my research into Jessie Reed is minimal at best. But for me these slivers of the past are like an old newsreel. The news may no longer be of any value, but one can’t help being entranced by the flickering lights and shadows of the passing parade. ![]()











